soy hulls vs beet pulp


cloud9gaits <cloud9gaits@...>
 

I saw in the letter to Equus that soy hulls are considered another safe
conduit for balancing additives. How do they compare to beet pulp?
Would you have to have them tested to be assured of levels low enough
to feed? Are they obtainable through feed mills? It is not easy to
find plain beet pulp in my area, hence my inquiry.
Paula


Eleanor Kellon, VMD
 

Not easy to find soy hulls either, but they compare very favorably to
beet pulp, similar safety and calories, more balanced mineral profile.
In the drawback category is dusty.

Eleanor


cloud9gaits <cloud9gaits@...>
 

I know that sometimes the beet pulp crop can be higher in natural
sugars and has to be soaked. Would this be the same with the soy hulls?
Paula


bchorse1 <cobble@...>
 

Do soy hulls interfere with the thyroid?
Leslie


Claire C. Cox-Wilson <shotgun.ranch@...>
 

--- In EquineCushings@..., "bchorse1" <cobble@...> wrote:

Do soy hulls interfere with the thyroid?
Leslie
That's the thought...
From Our AVOID THESE ITEMS file:
"SOY should only be fed in small amounts & cautiously as researchers
have identified that the isoflavones act as potent anti-thyroid
agents, and are capable of suppressing thyroid function, and causing
or worsening hypothyroidism in humans."
I'd be careful.
Claire from AZ


cloud9gaits <cloud9gaits@...>
 

OK..now I'm really confused. Why would Dr. K recommend soy hulls to be
used like beet pulp if this was a problem?
Paula


Eleanor Kellon, VMD
 

--- In EquineCushings@..., "Claire C. Cox-Wilson"
<shotgun.ranch@...> wrote:

That's the thought...
From Our AVOID THESE ITEMS file:
"SOY should only be fed in small amounts & cautiously as researchers
have identified that the isoflavones act as potent anti-thyroid
agents, and are capable of suppressing thyroid function, and causing
or worsening hypothyroidism in humans."
I'd be careful.
Good thought, Claire, but the hulls themselves don't contain the
isoflavones, only the meal.

Eleanor


cloud9gaits <cloud9gaits@...>
 

The last question was, do NSC levels have to be checked on the soy
hulls, with subsequent soaking if too high?..or are they pretty much
always within a good range.
Paula


Eleanor Kellon, VMD
 

--- In EquineCushings@..., "cloud9gaits" <cloud9gaits@...>
wrote:

The last question was, do NSC levels have to be checked on the soy
hulls, with subsequent soaking if too high?..or are they pretty much
always within a good range.
All the average analysis figures I've seen have them below 10% for
sugar + starch combined.

Eleanor


bchorse1 <cobble@...>
 

Thanks for clearing that up. I can get them from a local feed mill.
Leslie
--- In EquineCushings@..., "Eleanor Kellon, VMD"
<drkellon@...> wrote:

--- In EquineCushings@..., "Claire C. Cox-Wilson"
<shotgun.ranch@> wrote:

That's the thought...
From Our AVOID THESE ITEMS file:
"SOY should only be fed in small amounts & cautiously as researchers
have identified that the isoflavones act as potent anti-thyroid
agents, and are capable of suppressing thyroid function, and causing
or worsening hypothyroidism in humans."
I'd be careful.
Good thought, Claire, but the hulls themselves don't contain the
isoflavones, only the meal.

Eleanor